And now a Viktor Shklovsky quote I found, courtesy of Aqueduct Press, for that segment of my readership who can never enough Shklovsky -- you know who you are.
"Thackeray resented the idea of dénouement. He compared it with the residue of tea on the bottom of a cup; it's too sugary. It's obvious to the reader that it is a condensation of unresolved conflicts."
"To humor himself, Thackeray wanted his footman to write the ending for him, after he was done cleaning his boots and dress."
I approve of this simile, but it makes me want to defend dénouement . Because I think I want to taste those over-saccharine last dregs, with their nonetheless-bitter aftertaste. That final gulp, that ultimate page, bring a presentiment of death, for isn't it always the footman who writes the ending? Cf. J. Alfred Prufrock --
"I have seen the moment of my greatness flicker,
And I have seen the eternal Footman hold my coat, and snicker...”
Shklovsky continues, "So then it appears that dénouements are based on the premise that they don't really exist."
This makes me think of Slavoj Žižek on "The Truman Show" -- "what if it is precisely this "happy" dénouement of the film... with the hero breaking out and, as we are led to believe, soon to join his true love... that is ideology at its purest? What if ideology resides in the very belief that, outside the closure of the finite universe, there is some 'true reality' to be entered?"
Could this be the residue we are straining to get a taste of at the bottom of the teacup? And remember that not all of us put sugar in our tea.