identity theory

interviews
fiction
nonfiction
music
social justice
film
books
visuals
verse
blogs


books

Book Rate

A digested book "review": cheap shots, glib commentary, shameless advocacy of insidious ideology of social and economic justice and idiosyncratic and totally arbitrary choices of books that come our way via our gallant and steadfast UPS drivers and other routes...

Maybe.

Note: (RB) = Robert Birnbaum; (RLW) = RL Whalen; (JT) = Janice Tsai; (AK) = Angie Kritenbrink; (MB) equals Matt Borondy; and soon enough there will be other abbreviations to deal with. Links go to Amazon.com.

Last updated: August 26, 2004

The Genius of Language: Fifteen Writers Reflect on Their Mother Tongues - Wendy Lesser (Pantheon, 241 p.p.)

Given the limitless pool of information that is accessible to the literate and semi literate in our brave new world, curatorial efforts will come to be seen as expressions of artistic talent—somewhat like the early FM radio free-form disc jockeys who segued music by Karlheinz Stockhausen, Howling Wolf, Charlie Parker and The Temptations. In that spirit, this is a genius anthology assembled by Threepenny Review's Wendy Lesser, who credits Joseph Conrad as "the great ancestor, the supervisory ghost" of this effort and uses his writing as the source of the book's title, "English for me was neither a matter of choice nor adoption… It was I who adopted the genius of language." Included are memoiristic essays by Bharati Mukherjee, Joseph Skvorecky, Amy Tan, Luc Sante, Louis Begley, Ariel Dorfman and Leonard Michaels. (RB)


History Lessons: How Textbooks From Around the World Portray US History - Dana Lindaman & Kyle Ward (New Press, 404 p.p.)

Given the undisputed xenophobia of Americans, one wonders if the people who are perhaps most in need of this instructive tome will make use of it. But then it is a matter of some argument whether Americans read their own history books. Francis Fitzgerald, whose America Revised: History Schoolbooks in the Twentieth Century admirably exhibits her expertise in this area, points out, "Reading a book composed entirely of excerpts from textbooks may seem an unpromising activity, but history texts reveal much about national perspectives and prejudices: They are more expressive than government pronouncements; they get into matters diplomats avoid; and yet, as the authors note, they are in varying degrees state-sanctioned and thus official, or semi-official, stories about the national past. Most reflect public attitudes; all help to create those attitudes because they are the most widely read histories in each country, and because kids read them during the formative adolescent years." This book goes a good distance in explaining the rest of the world's lack of reverence for America, something that seems to baffle Americans. (RB)


Paris Review #170 - Summer 2004 (206 p.p.)

Paris Review senior editor Oliver Broudy interviews Paula Fox. Novelist John Wray (The Right Hand of God) interviews Haruki Murakami. Stories by Nathaniel Bellows (On This Day) and Ignacio Padilla (Shadow Without A Name) and the usual unusual literary morsels in this first post-George Plimpton edition. (RB)


Borges: a life – Edwin Williamson (Viking, 571 p.p.)

Last year brought forth a slew of extensive biographies of writers: two on George Orwell (being the centenary of his birth), Geoffrey Wolf on John O'Hara, Blake Bailey's invaluable work on the inestimable Richard Yates, and Garcia Marquez's first volume of a proposed memorial trilogy. The trickle has slowed to a drip-drop this year, supplanted with books reflecting our plague time. Oxford don Williamson who is known as (well, by the people who know about such things) a Cervantes scholar has brought forth his contribution to Borgesian scholarship—which now numbers at least a dozen biographies (according to this books bibliography). Perhaps this betrays a streak of my own latent philistinism, but I am particularly fond of the biographical essays that James Atlas' Penguin Lives sponsored. And in that spirit I would be thrilled to read Elliot Weinberger on Borges—as opposed to wading through five or six hundred pages to glean a few pages of value (to me). (RB)


Irreparable Harm - Renata Adler (Melville House, 61 p.p.)
The Road to Illegitimacy - Mark Danner (Melville House, 60 p.p.)
The Big Chill - Dennis Loy Johnson (Melville House, 109 p.p.)

Journalist, writer and literary enthusiast Dennis Loy Johnson, whose worthy and useful webzine Moby Lives (wherein he tilted at various cultural windmills and which has been on hiatus) justifies his absence from the fray with the pride of Hoboken, Melville House's publication of a troika of well designed broadsides on the great black mark of American electoral politics, the 2000 presidential election. On the heels of the lovingly published series The Art of the Novella; Melville's Bartelby the Scrivener, Chekov's My Life, Tolstoy's My Life, Henry James' The Lesson of the Master and Frank O'Connor's long essay on the short story, The Lonely Voice, we think that light and hopes of literature are alive and well in Hoboken. (RB)


The Believer
- August 2004 # 20 (88 p.p.)

Susan Choi (American Girl) chats with Francisco Goldman (The Divine Husband), Howard Hampton looks at Jonathan Ames' latest (Wake Up! Sir) and Ben Ehrenreich's riveting feature "Labels Can Really Kill A Person" on so-called Sexually Violent Predators and Ann Cummins (Red House) reviews Karen Shepard's The Bad Boy's Wife (see below). (RB)


Ulysses S Grant – Josiah Bunting III (Times Books, 180 p.p.)

Reading Josiah Bunting's revisionist (in the sense that he corrects the conventional view) take on Grant, I confess to having held the popular views that he was both a drunkard and butcher. Earlier in the year, reading Rachel Cohen's A Chance Meeting, my view of US Grant was rehabilitated by being apprised of his friendship with Mark Twain. And there is, of course, Mark Perry's Grant and Twain: The Story of a Friendship That Changed America. This slender volume serves to fill in the blanks in my historical knowledge and lays much of the misconception about Grant at his own reticence and taciturnity. Historian Bunting has an amusingly florid prose style and his choice of epigraph for this book quotes Michael Beckerman, "It is not easy to discern the motives of any action by any person, especially since our reasons for doing something are often hidden even to ourselves…Those who do not explain themselves often find themselves explained by others." This study is part of an ongoing series on American president that has Arthur Schlesinger as its executive editor, which isn't necessarily a bad thing—though I must admit to my own disenchantment with the famous Camelot historian. But that's another story for another day. (RB)


Ploughshares Fall 2004, guest edited by Amy Bloom (218 p.p.)

I thought to reproduce the entirety of Amy Bloom's introduction to this edition of Ploughshares, but then what would you do:

A friend of mine finds out from her agent (her editor never calls) that her book, her fourth, has been dropped from her publisher’s catalogue. The work is too difficult. A writer I know is told, “How about putting in some dogs? People love it when you write about dogs.” An editor I admire, at a magazine I have long admired, says, “We’re just not doing emotionally complex work. All I wanted to do in this issue was to find room for difficult work, for emotionally complex work, for work that didn’t have dogs where they didn’t belong and for work that loved the word, as well as the story, and believed in telling a story that mattered, in a way that stayed with me, stayed with you, and didn’t shy from imagination or get coy about facts." Twelve stories and an essay are the results of Bloom's personal culling. (RB)


The Bad Boy's Wife – Karen Shepard (St Martins, 253 p.p.)

Karen Shepard (An Empire of Women) deftly tells (in reverse) the story of Hannah and Cole's 20-year marriage starting 2 years after it falls apart. We share Andrea Barrett's take, "This portrait of a marriage gains unusual power and poetry through its deft inversions of the past." Especially poignant are the relationship and the dilemma of divorce as seen through the eyes of Mattie, the 10-year-old daughter. (RB)


Coast to Coast: A Family Romance – Nora Johnson (Simon & Schuster, 275 p.p.)

Novelist Nora Johnson's (The World of Henry Orient) pedigree and the basis for this book is her father, the great screenwriter and director Nunnally Johnson (The Grapes of Wrath, The Dirty Dozen, How to Marry A Millionaire)—whose observation, "Only a hack is consistent," gave him an unchallenged entry into my personal pantheon of O.H.C. (Observers of the Human Condition). Nora recounts, "I was ridiculously in love with my father. We both knew it. So were a lot of others—his three wives and [five] children, his secretaries and maids and movie stars and almost everyone he encountered—which transformed my feeling into a public commodity." This is Johnson's account of shuttling between her divorced parents in the 1940's and '50s and all the attendant glamour of chic New York and glitzy Hollywood society, rife with anecdotes of the famous and a fair measure of poignancy. (RB)

join
sign up for the identity theory newsletter.

your e-mail:

tell a friend

Print this page
E-mail this page

All work on Identity Theory -- with the exception of the public-domain classics -- is copyright its original author. The site is best viewed with the most recent version of Internet Explorer.